[Date Prev][Date Next]
[cdn-nucl-l] Ex-Environmental Leaders Tout Nuclear Energy
Ex-Environmental Leaders Tout Nuclear Energy
By MATTHEW L. WALD
Published: April 25, 2006
WASHINGTON, April 24 -
The nuclear industry has hired Christie Whitman, the former administrator of
the Environmental Protection Agency, and Patrick Moore, a co-founder of
Greenpeace, the environmental organization, to lead a public relations
campaign for new reactors.
Nuclear power is "environmentally friendly, affordable, clean, dependable
and safe," Mrs. Whitman said at a news conference on Monday. She said that
as the E.P.A. leader for two and a half years, ending in June 2003, and as
governor of New Jersey for seven years, she had promoted various means to
reduce the emission of gases that cause global warming and pollution.
But Mrs. Whitman said that "none of them will have as great a positive
impact on our environment as will increasing our ability to generate
electricity from nuclear power."
Mrs. Whitman headed the E.P.A. when it published rules for the proposed
high-level nuclear waste repository at Yucca Mountain in Nevada. After she
left the office, the courts threw out the rules because they covered only
the first 10,000 years of waste storage, while peak releases of radiation
were expected after that time.
Organizers released a list of 58 companies and institutions and 10 people
who they said were members of a new Clean and Safe Energy Coalition, which
Mr. Moore said would engage in "grass-roots advocacy." A spokesman for the
Nuclear Energy Institute, the trade association of reactor operators,
acknowledged that it was providing all of the financing, but would not say
what the budget was.
Mr. Moore said he favored efficiency and renewable energy, but added that
solar cells, which produce electricity from sunlight, were "being given too
much emphasis and taking too much money." A dollar spent on geothermal
energy, he said, was "10 to 12 times more effective in reducing greenhouse
Mr. Moore is the director of a company that distributes geothermal systems
in Canada. He is also a supporter of what he called "sustainable forestry"
because, he said, building with wood avoided the use of materials whose
manufacture releases greenhouse gases, like steel and concrete.
Mr. Moore, who left Greenpeace in 1986, favors many technologies that some
environmentalists oppose, including the genetic engineering of crops, and
has referred to his former colleagues as "environmental extremists" and
Mr. Moore said Greenpeace was wrong to oppose nuclear energy, which he
called essential to reducing global warming gases. Coincidentally,
Greenpeace released a report on Monday about 200 failures at American
nuclear power plants, which it described as "near misses," since 1986. The
report was to mark the 20th anniversary of the Chernobyl nuclear plant
explosion in the former Soviet Union.
Mrs. Whitman also referred to Chernobyl, saying people "still think in terms
of Bhopal and Chernobyl." A leak at a chemical plant in Bhopal, India,
killed more than 2,500 people in December 1984. But nuclear power, she said,
"can be safely and appropriately used to expand our mix."
Representatives of the United States Chamber of Commerce and the Teamsters
also spoke in favor of new reactors.